On this page
Filing & corrections
Why does Form W-2G say withholding is too high?
Check the winnings and withholding fields against your records. Ask support if accurate amounts still fail the check.
Updated
What the app checks
E-File Magic compares Federal Income Tax Withheld in Box 4 with Reportable Winnings in Box 1. Its current validation rejects positive withholding without winnings and withholding above 36% of the reported winnings.
Check the amounts and column matches
Compare both fields with your records. Winnings and tax withheld belong in separate fields. Correct any typo or import mapping error, then save again.
If the amounts are accurate and the error remains, contact support before filing. Do not reduce accurate withholding or increase winnings to make the form pass.
The check does not decide your tax treatment
This is an application validation check. It does not determine the withholding rate you should use, whether payer-paid tax needs an adjustment or whether another filing method is suitable. Use the current instructions and your tax preparer for those questions.