Skip to article content
Retirement

2026 reporting; cross-year examples are expressly identified.

An IRA-to-Roth Conversion: Reconcile the Sending and Receiving Forms

Reconcile a traditional IRA-to-Roth conversion across Form 1099-R and Form 5498, including withholding differences and the limits of custodian knowledge.

Published 4 min read

Source review: · Updated

Filing guide
In this guide

A traditional IRA-to-Roth IRA conversion is not an ordinary transfer between two accounts of the same type. Even when the same financial institution handles both accounts and no cash leaves its systems, the conversion creates reporting on the sending and receiving sides.

The custodian's job is to record the conversion correctly without pretending to know every fact that determines the individual's taxable income.

A hypothetical same-institution conversion

An IRA owner, age 45, instructs a custodian to convert $20,000 from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA during 2026. Assume the full amount reaches the Roth IRA, no withholding occurs, and the transaction is a valid conversion rather than a recharacterization or an ordinary contribution.

The sending custodian reports the $20,000 traditional IRA distribution in Form 1099-R boxes 1 and 2a under the IRA instructions and generally checks the taxable-amount-not-determined box. For this owner, code 2 applies to the known conversion under the instructions. The receiving custodian reports $20,000 in Form 5498 box 3, the Roth IRA conversion field.

Box 2a does not mean the custodian has reconstructed the owner's basis in every traditional IRA. The individual's ultimate taxable conversion calculation may require information the custodian does not possess.

Why the two forms serve different purposes

Form 1099-R describes the outgoing distribution. Form 5498 describes the amount received as a Roth conversion contribution. They should be reconcilable, but the forms do not have identical fields or identical roles.

Do not map the incoming amount to the regular Roth contribution field simply because it arrived in a Roth account. Similarly, a rollover from a qualified plan to a Roth IRA has a different Form 5498 classification from a traditional IRA conversion. Identify the source arrangement before choosing the receiving box.

The same distinction matters for annual contribution limits. A conversion is not an ordinary annual contribution merely because it increases the Roth balance. The filer should not reject the reporting amount because it exceeds the regular contribution limit.

Withholding changes the reconciliation

The simple example assumes no withholding. If money is withheld from the traditional IRA distribution, the amount distributed and the amount actually placed in the Roth IRA can differ. Preserve the gross distribution, withholding and conversion deposit separately.

For example, if $20,000 leaves the traditional IRA but $2,000 is withheld and only $18,000 reaches the Roth IRA, the tax-reporting team should not automatically force both forms to show a $20,000 conversion receipt. Any additional funds supplied by the owner and the timing and treatment of those funds must be reviewed on their facts.

Do not infer a contribution simply to make the two sides agree. A reconciliation should explain differences, not erase them.

Maintain an auditable conversion instruction

Keep the signed or otherwise valid conversion direction, source and destination account types, owner identity, execution date, asset valuation and withholding instruction. For an in-kind conversion, retain the valuation evidence used for the transferred assets.

Check the distribution code against the owner's age and the specific transaction. The 2026 instructions distinguish codes 2 and 7 for known traditional IRA conversions. Avoid assigning a code based only on the receiving account's name.

Also retain records of any failed or reversed processing. A customer saying “undo the conversion” does not establish that a later transaction can be reported as a permissible recharacterization. Conversions made in 2018 or later cannot be recharacterized under the rule described in the IRS instructions.

Before filing

Review the outgoing and incoming files together. Confirm that the Form 5498 conversion field contains the amount actually classified as received for that purpose and that Form 1099-R follows the applicable distribution rules. Leave the individual's cross-account basis calculation to the individual and their adviser.

Keep the sending and receiving records visible as you prepare Form 1099-R and Form 5498 in E-File Magic. Import or enter the approved conversion and withholding amounts, then compare the prepared forms with the institution's reconciliation. That gives the conversion a clear reporting handoff while preserving the transaction evidence behind the two forms.

Source: IRS 2026 Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498, [1]. Reviewed October 7, 2026.

PUT YOUR GUIDE INTO PRACTICE

Put your filing plan into practice.

Start with your reviewed records, or contact our team to confirm the services your filing needs.

The official reference

IRS instructions for this guide

Preview here, or save a copy for later.

Tax year 2026
1 PDF for tax year 2026.
Browse the instruction library

Need another form or year? Explore the full library. Edition dates reflect the IRS publication and may differ from the tax year.

Sources & further reading

Official references used in this guide. Check the applicable form revision and current instructions for your filing year.

  1. IRS instructions: 1099R
All articles